First things first...I'm sorry it's been almost 18 months since I've posted here. I've had a lot going on personally, (and frankly, my life is still a little all over the place) and blogging just wasn't a top priority. However, I couldn't simply ignore this topic, and I felt compelled to sit down and type something to share with all of you. Oddly enough, the topic at hand does kind of suit my blog doesn't it? I mean my original intent with this blog was to examine and embrace all forms of beauty around us.
As some of you know, one of my childhood friends was competing for Miss America 2014. Even though she's an incredibly talented dancer, gorgeous, intelligent, and well-spoken, she didn't make the "Top 15." Aside from her participation, I had no reason or interest to stay tuned in to the broadcast of the pageant unless you count Sunday evening boredom...
But I did end up watching the rest of the pageant, and I'm glad I did. I was absolutely ecstatic that the top two ladies were Asian Americans. To me, the reality that for the first time ever, two women of full Asian descent occupied the top two spots at Miss America was exciting. I am thrilled that Miss New York Nina Davuluri, an Indian American woman, who sees herself as more American than Indian, won. What makes her remarkable is how very open she's been about her past struggles with bulimia, especially since her parents, who are immigrants, didn't really understand what she was dealing with nor how to respond as eating disorders are not as common in Asian societies. (In fact, Nina herself refuses to reveal her weight publicly...not because of her past body image struggles but rather so that other girls and women can not use that information as motivation)
Appropriately, the "final question" she was asked dealt with Julie Chen's recent revelation about her choice (due to pressure from others -- for the record, this is a topic I want to explore in a whole separate blog post) to undergo plastic surgery on her eyes so that she would appear "less Asian" and the message it sends to young women across the country. Nina didn't shy away from any aspect of the question. While, she acknowledged that she understood why Julie chose to have the surgery, Nina also affirmed that she personally did not believe in plastic surgery. She spoke about how we all need to embrace who we are as individuals and that people should NEVER feel like plastic surgery is necessary to make us or others happy with how we look.
However, I found the most remarkable part of her response to be this, "I've always viewed Miss America as the girl next door, and the girl next door is evolving as a diverse America evolves. She's not who she was 10 years ago, and she's not going to be the same person come 10 years down the road."
Nina managed to take something "small," like how a prominent female Asian American news anchor felt that plastic surgery was necessary so that she could achieve her goals in the realm of her career because she wasn't "white" enough, and apply it to America as a whole by using the idea of Miss America. Miss America is supposed to represent us, the people of this great country, the most diverse in the world, one giant melting pot of identities and cultures. Being different is what makes us Americans. Nina basically called out society on still insisting on defining America by its "whiteness." She reminds us that we should realize that the "'all-American, blonde-hair, blue-eyed' girl next door" is not actually the "girl next door" anymore.
I'll refrain from going in depth and inferring longterm effects of Nina's win or what I believe that she will/can accomplish as Miss America. Nonetheless, she possesses several attributes that will serve her well and really impressed me. In short, she's beautiful, intelligent, driven, and very well-spoken. Most importantly, she understands what being Miss America means not only to her but to young women in this country. She's going to give minority populations a voice and work on her platform to get America to "celebrate diversity through cultural competency."
She is a role model and advocate for how we should embrace and celebrate diversity in this country, and she knows that it doesn't begin with her winning Miss America. Rather, her awareness and understanding of her platform begins with how she identifies herself and who she is, especially if you take her comment prior to being crowned into account. She already recognized that it was a special and ground-breaking moment for two Asian America women to be the last two standing. This also seems like a good -- and necessary -- moment to point out that pageant organizers/insiders encouraged her to not do a Bollywood dance for her talent as it would be viewed as "too foreign." As we all saw, she didn't take that suggestion to heart. She now has an opportunity to encourage change and increase awareness in our society, and I do not doubt her ability to achieve these goals during her reign. Nina's advocacy for her platform began the minute she took that stage in the competition, and she's already working to spread her message as she eloquently fielded questions with the media -- in her post-win press conference to be exact -- regarding the negative feedback/outrage about her win (just google it if you want more).
She is a role model and advocate for how we should embrace and celebrate diversity in this country, and she knows that it doesn't begin with her winning Miss America. Rather, her awareness and understanding of her platform begins with how she identifies herself and who she is, especially if you take her comment prior to being crowned into account. She already recognized that it was a special and ground-breaking moment for two Asian America women to be the last two standing. This also seems like a good -- and necessary -- moment to point out that pageant organizers/insiders encouraged her to not do a Bollywood dance for her talent as it would be viewed as "too foreign." As we all saw, she didn't take that suggestion to heart. She now has an opportunity to encourage change and increase awareness in our society, and I do not doubt her ability to achieve these goals during her reign. Nina's advocacy for her platform began the minute she took that stage in the competition, and she's already working to spread her message as she eloquently fielded questions with the media -- in her post-win press conference to be exact -- regarding the negative feedback/outrage about her win (just google it if you want more).
Yes, I may be particularly passionate about this situation because I am an Asian American woman, I am friends with a contestant -- which in turn meant that I wasn't actually prepared to root for anyone else after the "Top 15" were revealed. (I thought about picking another contestant but ultimately, I didn't. Instead, I watched 15 wonderful women compete to the best of their abilities and just crossed my fingers and hoped that whoever did win was worthy of the title...for the record, Nina is). If having a personal interest in the matter wasn't enough, I spent a good portion of my undergraduate degree in history on coursework and discourse dealing with racial/ethnic identity and racism, especially with how it relates to historical events and the shaping of a country's history and identity, both of America and elsewhere. It's rather disheartening that something that should be in the past is still alive and well, if not even more prevalent and obvious in the present (i mean, did we really fail to learn from history?).
So to the people who are embarrassing themselves -- and disappointing me, and making me re-evaluate the
This is not a battle that can be won in a year, and it would be naïve to think that the opinions of America will change completely or even a little bit because of the result of a pageant. Nevertheless, I can only hope that it will play a role in helping our country understand and embrace its diversity and each other as Americans. I was raised to believe and taught that America is a true melting pot of backgrounds, and physically, we already are. So let's all take Nina's message to heart and aim to one day change the definition of "American" so that it's no longer synonymous with "white/whiteness." Let's alter that standard and start believing that "diversity/diverse" is the ONLY word that can describe America.
By winning the title of Miss America 2014, Nina Davuluri, an Indian American woman born of immigrant parents, changed the face of America. She's won the crown and now has the position and ability to make a difference in this country over the next year (and possibly beyond). Her platform of "celebrating diversity through cultural competency" seems particularly relevant in the wake of the response her win stirred. What about the rest of us? How will we respond? What are we going to do? Will we change our opinions and how we view each other? Are we going to step up with Nina and advocate for this message and or not all?
...the ball's in your court, America.
Don't hesitate to leave your thoughts and comments below!
Don't hesitate to leave your thoughts and comments below!